Print Friendly and PDF
Recall of the Week: Ryobi ¼ sheet sanders due to laceration hazard
Consumer groups urge Congress to reject bill that weakens product safety laws

Fact or fiction? Eight myths about your car

By Lou Carlozo, Guest Blogger
Green Dad Columnist for dealnews

The Kelley Blue Book folks have just named their Top 10 Green Cars for the 2011 calendar year, a seeming boon for drivers seeking eco-friendly automotive alternatives. But if you’re anything like me, you might think it’s not easy being green, especially when the path to environmental friendliness runs straight through your wallet like a Hummer on steroids.

Gas pump yellow A bare-bones 2012 Ford Focus – No. 10 on the Kelley list – runs $16,270. And that’s cheap compared to the fourth-ranked Lexus CT 200h, weighing in at $29,120, also without options. Ugh. To add insult to injury, any new car depreciates the second you drive it off the lot.

So for those of us who don’t have five figures to spend on a gleaming set of wheels, take heart: The greenest car may well be the one you already have, provided you take steps to make it more fuel-efficient and environmentally sound. This is especially so because you're going need those five figures to pay for skyrocketing gasoline this summer. In this post, Green Dad sorts the myths from facts when it comes to making your machine run in harmony with the planet.

Fact: Driving slower saves you gas.

Like millions of Americans, I listen to the "Car Talk" guys on National Public Radio mostly because they make me laugh. But they also dispense great auto advice, and they stress that slowing down makes a big difference: For every 1,000 miles you drive (figuring gas at $2.50 a gallon and 25 MPG fuel efficiency), you’ll save as much as $15 driving 10 mph slower. Of course, with gas nearly double that price now, the savings should double as well. Something to think about if you’re a speed demon.

Myth: Replacing the air filter on your car improves mileage.

Every time I go for a quickie oil change, the tech comes out with an air filter that looks like dirt, which shames me into coughing up to replace it. But if your motivation is better gas mileage, consider skipping the change. The U.S. Department of Energy reports that an air filter change will mostly help your acceleration, not your mileage – though if you drive an older car with a carbureted engine, it may improve fuel economy 2 percent to 6percent.

Fact: Stepping on the brakes wastes gas.

This one also comes courtesy of Click and Clack on "Car Talk." "Every time you use the brakes, you’re wasting the ‘acceleration’ you’ve already used.” Instead of moving your car, that energy is being transformed into steaming hot brake pads, they say. Instead, learn to anticipate stops, and gently accelerate your car from a standing stop.

Myth: Gas-saving additives can improve fuel economy by 20 percent or more.

What’s the difference between motor oil and snake oil? Not much, if you’re weighing the claims of slick entrepreneurs who know the timing’s right for selling you magical gas-saving potions. To be sure, some long-standing products with modest claims (such as STP Gas Treatment) have vigorous supporters, but they only claim to boost mileage about 10 percent. But as the Federal Trade Commission warns, "The Environmental Protection Agency has evaluated or tested more than 100 alleged gas-saving devices and has not found any product that significantly improves gas mileage. In fact, some ‘gas-saving’ products may damage a car’s engine or cause substantial increases in exhaust emissions.”

Myth: New "low-resistance" tires significantly improve gas mileage.

Unless you’re driving bald or severely under-inflated tires, the hype about low-rolling resistance tires adds up to minimal gas savings. As this story by USA Today reports, various brands of these newfangled tires create gas savings of only 1 percent to 3 percent, even if rolling resistance is cut by 25 percent or more. Whether that saves wear and tear on your car is another story, but the mileage improvements won’t even pay for a spare tire over the course of 10 tanks of gas.

Fact: You can realize dramatic mileage improvement by replacing your oxygen sensor.

This falls under the category of tuning up your car; always a good idea if you want to see gas mileage gains in the 4 percent range. As a function of any proper tune-up, ask your mechanic to look at the oxygen sensor; if it’s not working properly, a simple repair to this part – commonly costing between $50 and $120 – could boost your mileage by as much as 40 percent, the U.S. Department of Energy states. Note that if you make this fix, it may take a few weeks for you to realize the improved mileage as your engine’s fuel-air ratio adjusts.

Myth: Topping off the gas tank is a good idea.

I know, I know: You’ve finally found the one pump between here and Logansport, Ind., that has affordable gas, so why not squeeze every last drop into your tank? While that sounds sensible at first blush, here’s the problem: Gas expands in warmer weather, which means topped off gas will likely wind up spilling out your tank. As if you needed more incentive, check out this warning from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency: "Topping off the gas tank can result in your paying for gasoline that is fed back into the station’s tanks because your gas tank is full." So unless you’re in the mood to pay the folks at Exxon or BP a little more for your fuel, stop topping off your tank.

Myth: High-octane gasoline improves your mileage.

I’m amazed to see that countless drivers still fall for this marketing gimmick, despite abundant evidence that high-octane gas is a waste of money. Props to the folks at for pointing this out, along with other gas-saving tips you can read here. Bottom line: Unless your car specifically requires premium, skip it and go for low-octane fuel.

Copyright 2011, Rita R. Robison, Consumer Specialist


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Stelle Courney

Hmm... That's a nifty list of myths you have there. I'm definitely taking note of the facts you've listed. The myths you've mentioned have shocked me a little, especially that bit about the high octane gasoline.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)